civil disobedience speech

http://debatepedia.idebate.org/en/index.php/Resolved:_In_a_democracy,_civil_disobedience_is_an_appropriate_weapon_in_the_fight_for_justice

Use the link above , in addition to any other resources to learn more about both sides of the civil disobedience issue.

Then prepare a 3-5 minute speech in which you argue one side of the following statement:

In a democracy, civil disobedience is an appropriate weapon in the fight for justice.

Your speech must include at least 1 example from history- (logical appeal) to support your posit on
and 1 emotional appeal
________________________________________
grades will be based as follows:

Position clearly stated 10
Logical appeal given 10
Emotional appeal given 10
Eye Contact/volume 5
Time 5


OR

Find an example of modern day- (post civil rights movement) civil disobedience through online research. In a 3-5 min speech explain both sides of the issue, explain what happened as a result of civil disobedience, and share with the class how you feel on the issue. Was the civil disobedience justified? explain

___________________________________
Grades based as follows:

Explain overall issue 10
Both sides explained clearly 10
your opinion on issue clearly stated 10
eye contact/ volume 5
time 5